I've traveled to Italy annually for the past 15 years. I always skip Capri for this neighboring island instead.

Ischia, an island in the Gulf of Naples, belongs on your Italy itinerary. It has gorgeous beaches, fewer crowds than Capri, ...
CNN

An electric revolution on Procida, the Italian island time forgot

Halfway between Ischia and Naples sits Procida, the smallest island in the bay. Capri, bedecked with luxury villas and upscale boutiques, has catered for tourists since Roman times; Ischia’s hot ...
Stars and Stripes

Procida offers beaches, fishing villages and old-world charm

Just a short ferry ride across the Bay of Naples, the peaceful island of Procida offers a relaxing way to spend a day, tantalizing visitors with its colorful homes, picturesque streets and stunning ...